Jocks really don't drink and 'brainiacs' don't study more: Researchers find 'dramatic misconceptions' of teenager's behaviour - even among other teens


comments

Teenagers really are misunderstood - even by other teens.

Researchers have found that adolescents have  major misconceptions of what their friends are doing when it comes to sex, drugs and studying.

They say teens tend to conform to stereotypes - thinking jocks study less and drink more, for instance.

Nor conforming: Researchers found that adolescents overestimate the amount of drug and alcohol use and sexual behaviours that many of their peers are engaging in.

Nor conforming: Researchers found that adolescents overestimate the amount of drug and alcohol use and sexual behaviours that many of their peers are engaging in.

THE FIVE TYPES OF TEEN 

Following a method commonly used in adolescent research, five reputation-based groups were identified: 

socially oriented 'populars,' 

athletically oriented jocks, 

deviant-oriented 'burnouts,' 

academically oriented brains and 

students who were not strongly affiliated with any specific crowd. 

Jocks and populars ranked higher in likability than burnouts and brains, and were thus identified as high-status. 

'When they are judging the popular crowd, the jocks, the burnouts or the brainy kids at school, the gist is that students in these crowds are misperceived,' said Geoffrey Cohen of Stanford Graduate School of Education who co-authored the study.

'They tend to misperceive what their peers are doing.

'So they are conforming to norms based not on reality but on stereotypes.'

The team found that adolescents overestimate the amount of drug and alcohol use and sexual behaviours that many of their peers are engaging in.

At the same time, they underestimate the amount of time their peers spend on studying or exercise.

The study examined the perceptions and behaviors of 235 10th-grade participants at a suburban, middle-income high school.

Following a method commonly used in adolescent research, five reputation-based groups were identified: socially oriented 'populars,' athletically oriented jocks, deviant-oriented 'burnouts,' academically oriented brains and students who were not strongly affiliated with any specific crowd. Jocks and populars ranked higher in likability than burnouts and brains, and were thus identified as high-status.

The 'brainy' crowd studied on average only about half the amount of time that their peers thought they did.

The 'brainy' crowd studied on average only about half the amount of time that their peers thought they did.

Students reported their engagement in various behaviors confidentially, allowing researchers to compare the actual and perceived behavior of the groups.

Comparisons between the groups, from what the individuals reported as their own behaviors to what others thought of them, clearly resulted in what the study called 'gross misperceptions.'

'This quest for identity can sometimes lead adolescents in the wrong direction,' Cohen said. 

'The lesson of this research,' said Cohen, 'is that people may conform to norms and identities that are in their head rather than in reality – both for good and, too often, for ill.'

WHAT THEY FOUND 

Even teens in the high-status groups had exaggerated perceptions of their own group peers' risky behaviors.

In the instance of cigarette use, students in the popular crowd reported that they smoked about 1.5 cigarettes a day in the past month, while others - both and outside the group - thought they smoked three cigarettes a day.

Jocks said they didn't smoke much at all but others estimated they smoked at least one cigarette per day.

Burnouts reported that they smoked about two to three cigarettes per day, but their peers pegged the perceived amount at a half-pack to a whole pack of cigarettes a day.

According to their schoolmates' perceptions, jocks not only smoked more, they binged on alcohol more and had more sex than what the jocks reported as their actual behavior.

Burnouts faced similarly significant misperceptions: yes, they smoked relatively more marijuana than other groups but not nearly as much as what their peers thought they did. The burnouts were also wrongly presumed to shoplift and damage property more frequently and study less than what they reported in reality.

In fact, jocks and popular teen-agers – the two social groups seen as having the greatest potential of influencing others' behavior – reported levels of sexual and deviant behaviors that were not significantly different from either the burnout or brainy groups, according to the study.

On the other hand, the brainy crowd studied on average only about half the amount of time that their peers thought they did. 

 



IFTTT

Put the internet to work for you.

Turn off or edit this Recipe

0 comments:

Post a Comment